Acoustic Guitars - The Best Tuners
Acoustic Guitar under $918-$999
Let’s start with the meticulously built
The American-made 410 scores points for its solid African mahogany back and sides. The Guild D6-S, competing in division 2, is the only other contestant with non-laminated body parts. Bob Taylor had some intriguing comments on the subject: “Typically, when you use a lot of plywood in guitars it gives them a generic tone. You don’t get the nuances of an individual piece of wood. However, many builders feel—and I agree—that a guitar’s sides should be stiff and strong, and the possibility exists for veneered sides to be every bit as good as solid ones. In fact,
The 410 boasts the best frets of the Shootout. They’re completely even on either side of the ebony fretboard, perfectly seated and crowned, with nary a file mark to be found. Folks, frets don’t get any better, but they sure get a lot worse, as we’ll see. In a break with
The
The
Sonically, the
The D-1, made in Martin’s
The Martin has a luminescent cross-link, environmentally friendly semi-gloss finish and beautiful tortoise-shell binding. Even the bridge pins have tortoise inlays. (“They’ve really succeeded in making it look like a more expensive Martin.”) The Gospel’s super-gloss finish looks stylish. (“Shiny, bright, and proud.”) Visually, both instruments upstage the decidedly plain-Jane 410. When it comes to workmanship, however, neither matches the
Both the D4 and Gospel have clean, trim interiors. (The D-1 smells great too.) The D-1 has generic imported die-cast tuners, the Gospel offers Deluxe Klusons, and the
The Martin has a glued neck joint. An internal bolt functions as a clamp to keep things aligned during the gluing process. After the fact, the bolt/clamp remains as a part of the instrument. The
Setup is first-rate on all three guitars. Time and again, however, the Gospel drew positive comments about its wider string spacing which I facilitates fingerpicking and just plain feels good.
Sonically, the D-1, 410, and Gospel acquit themselves superbly. The Gospel, with its strong, almost brash sound, turned heads each time it was played. The ax (which boasts a lifetime warranty) delivers a very satisfying tschank when you punch an open E chord When you caress a single note, the over tones sustain and sing. The comments were impassioned: “An old J-45, it’s in there.” “This is what everyone wants Gibsons to sound like.” “A vintage
Flat tops Acoustic Guitar Guide
Rating solid-top acoustic guitars under $999 USD
On the best guitars, the builder finds a nice, resonant tonewood board, cuts it in half like you’d fillet a trout, opens the halves to expose a symmetrical, mirrored grain pattern, and glues the pieces side by side. This process is called bookmatch lug. A solid top adds significantly to the instrument’s cost. If you’re serious about tone, how ever, it’s the only way to go.
The criteria. We invited dozens of manufacturers to participate in our Shootout; each was allowed to submit one instrument per brand name. (Only two companies submitted instruments with different marques: St. Louis Music sent us an Alvarez and a Yairi, Martin entered a Martin and a Sigma.) Our contest rules were simple: The entrant must be a 6- string, steel-string acoustic with a solid-wood top and retail price of under $1,000, sans case.
Ellen Sorstokke of Saga, one of our contestants, gave us food for thought. “There’s a huge difference,:’ she reminded us, “between a $300, $600, and $1,000 guitar. Even a $100 difference can be meaningful.” To avoid any “apples to oranges” accusations and ensure a level playing field, we divided our contestants in to five groups based on list price. (If you shop aggressively, you’ll pay less than list.) The price spreads within these divisions range from $77 to as little as $30.50. Each guitar competes against class members, but we don’t hesitate to laud a lower-priced instrument when it outperforms a higher-priced one in a given category.
Testing. Five GP editors participated in the evaluations. All have considerable experience playing and recording acoustics; some have focused principally on acoustic music for years at a stretch. Contrary to what one manufacturer implied at the outset of our Shootout, none of us are “electric guitar weenies with a serious attitude problem regarding acoustic instruments.” (Actually, “weenies with attitudes” has a rather nice ring, don’t you think? Perhaps this warrants a T-shirt.)
To provide essential counterpoint to our views, we asked Martin Simpson (interviewed Aug. ‘93) and Lyle Workman (Bourgeois Tagg, Jellyfish, Todd Rundgren)—two world-class players with extensive performing and recording credits—to give us their unvarnished opinions. Other visiting pickers were pressed into service on a less official basis.
Armed with a Steelman gooseneck inspection mirror (amateur proctologists unite!), a Seiko 5T1200 chromatic tuner, a steel ruler, feeler gauges, sets of Martin phosphor bronze lights and Dean Markley bronze mediums, and a fistful of assorted picks, we held numerous testing sessions. As few as four and as many as seven players and listeners attended these events. You’ll find their comments sprinkles throughout the Shootout. As you’d expect, we didn’t always reach a consensus. At times, you’ll have to draw your own conclusions from conflicting opinions.
Regarding playability: We first evaluated each instrument’s factory setup (virtually all instruments arrived with light-gauge strings). If there was a problem, we tweaked the truss rod and changed strings, noting how well a guitar responded to our efforts to reduce buzz or increase sustain, In the write up, we include physical details that pertain to our observations. For a complete lowdown on nut width, scale length, bridge material, and the like, refer to the chart above.
The fine print Ibanez and Epiphone are conspicuously absent from the fray. Both companies were in the middle of redesigning their line and didn’t have production instrument ready.
Because wood is organic, it’s impossible to guarantee consistency within a model line. Sonic variations—sometimes startling ones— are inevitable. We stand behind our conclusions 100%, but remember, they’re based on the specific instruments we cradled, picked, strummed, and lived with. Augment our re search with your own testing. (See “Flat-Top Shopping Tips.”)
ok that's it let see who is worth buying....uder $999 USD